The models of fol, called rst order structures, as well as its complete gentzen deduction system are well understood and intuitive, thus making fol an attractive formalism with many. Originally designed as tools for mathematicians, modern applications of automated theorem provers and proof assistants are much more diverse. First, we establish the first known collapse result for the quantifier alternation of mso logic over countable linear orderings. Firstorder logic, even restricted to only horn clauses, is semidecidable. Look in chapters 4 and 5 for excellent presentation of material on first order logic, herbrands theorem and compactness theorem. A resolution calculus for secondorder logic with eager. In this section, we will go through logicbased models that use logical formulas and inference rules.
Semidecidability of first order logic it is possible to determine unsatisfiability of a formula by showing that it leads to a contradiction an empty clause implication of semidecidability we cannot prove a goal directly but must show that adding the negation of the goal to the program pmakes punsatisfiable. Let us call a formal language semi decidable if there is a computable algorithm that, given a formula of the language as input, will output \yes if the formula is valid and will not say \yes and perhaps will not even halt otherwise. Every city has a postman that has been bitten by every dog in town. If the semidecidable can be approximated by and by, then we have the following table.
Carlos bacelar almeida, dium validity checking propositional and firstorder logic 543 validity checking in propositional logic general remarks the structure of logical validity allows for much better algorithms. Prenex normal form wikipedia first order resolution clausal form, unification, resolution method for first. Semidecidability of validity lower bound for validity compactness theorem of firstorder logic 5 deductive perspective on predicate logic logical consequence the deductive system f first order theories axiomatization 6 algorithmic perspective on predicate logic semantic tableaux uni. Decidable fragments of firstorder language under stable model semantics and circumscription conference paper pdf available july 2010 with 64 reads how we measure reads. The other two aspects are very intimately connected with this one. Firstorder logic introduction universidade do minho. The idea here is to balance expressivity and computational efficiency. Semidecidability, of course, makes the predicate calculus inherently intractable. Recall that a semi decision procedure for validity should halt and return \valid when given a valid formula as input, but otherwise may compute forever.
If there are no live bacteria in a jar, then it is sterile. In logic, a truefalse decision problem is decidable if there exists an effective method for deriving the correct answer. Logical systems extending first order logic, such as second order logic and type theory, are also undecidable. Aug 19, 20 abstract the efficiency of the first order resolution calculus is impaired when lifting it to higher order logic. Completeness and semi decidability for first order logic. Write the following statements in first order logic. Example resolution animal y x loves z x x loves u v kills. The temporal logic of reactive and concurrent systems. One result of this semi decidability is that many problems are. If a jar is sterile, then there are no live bacteria in it. Tgl has a complete gentzen system generalizing that of.
Decidable fragments of firstorder logic and of firstorder. Firstorder logic firstorder semantic structures, formal language, variables and quantifiers, satisfaction, entailment. Classical firstorder logic introduction universidade do minho. Review of sets, relations, computability, propositional and first order logic syntax, semantics, sequent calculus. If you feel a sentence is ambiguous, clarify which meaning youre representing in logic. Entailment in predicate logic is only semi decidable. One result of this semidecidability is that many problems are. We show that, in a fairly general setting including highertypes, may, must and probabilistic testing are semidecidable. Machine learning and automated theorem proving james p.
In order to construct valid forms of arguments one has to know what such forms can be built from, that is, determine the ultimate \building blocks. Second, we solve an open problem posed by gurevich and rabinovich, concerning the msodefinability of sets of rational numbers using the reals in the background. The decision problem of validity in firstorder logic is semidecidable. Keywords generic rst order logic, substitution, calculus 1. I know the practical consequences of semidecidability of first order logic. First order logic fol syntax o terms, predicates, atoms, literals, quantifiers, wff semantics o interpretations and models, valid, satisfiable, and inconsistent sentences, logical consequences o be able to translate between english sentences and fol sentences o soundness and completeness of proof theory in fol.
If there exists a finite, decidable, or semidecidable axiomatization. If the semi decidable can be approximated by and by, then we have the following table. The problem ilp adthe core of the intuitive theory of kinship in western culture dresses is. Semi decidability of first order logic it is possible to determine unsatisfiability of a formula by showing that it leads to a contradiction an empty clause implication of semi decidability we cannot prove a goal directly but must show that adding the negation of the goal to the program p makes p unsatisfiable. In computability theory and computational complexity theory, an undecidable problem is a decision problem for which it is proved to be impossible to construct an algorithm that always leads to a correct yesorno answer. A problem is semidecidable if there exists a procedure that. First order logic first order semantic structures, formal language, variables and quantifiers, satisfaction, entailment. Lecture 17 of 41 clausal conjunctive normal form and.
Semi decidability of first order logic it is possible to determine unsatisfiability of a formula by showing that it leads to a contradiction an empty clause implication of semi decidability we cannot prove a goal directly but must show that adding the negation of the goal to the program pmakes punsatisfiable. Abstract the efficiency of the firstorder resolution calculus is impaired when lifting it to higherorder logic. Problem 3 representing knowledge with firstorder logic 25 points a convert each of the following english sentences into firstorder predicate calculus fopc, using reasonably named predicates, functions, and constants. That is, why can i verify the validity of a theorem in a finite number of steps, but if the. Resolution refutation an overview sciencedirect topics. Specification by zohar manna and amir pnueli, springer verlag.
Recall that a semidecision procedure for validity should halt and return \valid when given a valid formula as input, but otherwise may compute forever. Undecidability of firstorder logic computer science new. Lecture 17 of 41 clausal conjunctive normal form and resolution techniques wednesday, 29 september 2004 william h. Introduction several frameworks such as assumption based truth maintenance systems 7, 8, 14 and etc. First order logic, prime implicates, consensus, subsumption 1. I studied the concepts of decidability, semi decidability and undecidability. Chapter 9 28 general case means, for full first order logic. N, called truncation, to obtain a natural formalization of partial recursive functions. Decidability implies semi decidability, so the language of. Entailment in propositional logic is decidable since truth tables can be applied in a finite number of steps to determine whether or not. Fragment of firstorder logic designed for logical representation of objectoriented formalisms framesclassesconcepts sets of objects rolesproperties binary relations on objects individuals representation as a collection of statements, with unary and binary predicates that stand for concepts and roles, from.
I studied the concepts of decidability, semidecidability and undecidability. What i dont understand are the profound reasons for which the first order logic is semi decidable. Lewis 33 showed that satisfiability is nexptimecomplete for ramseys class and kolaitis and vardi 29 proved that a 01 law holds for existential secondorder logic where the firstorder part. We found that resolution for propositional logic was sound and complete. Cityx means x is a city postmanx means x is a postman dogx means x is a dog livesx,y means x lives in city y bitx,y means x bit y 2. The rcalculus and the finite injury priority method. What i dont understand are the profound reasons for which the first order logic is semidecidable. Introduction eral because of the semidecidability of. Example resolution animal y x loves z x x loves u v kills u v animal y x kills from cs 221 at stanford university. Pdf decidable fragments of firstorder language under.
Fol is often called semidecidable since although there are. The main reason for that is the semi decidability and infinitary nature of higher order unification algorithms, which requires the integration of unification within the calculus and results in a nonefficient search for refutations. Semidecidability of first order logic mathematics stack. Introduction first order logic fol is one of the bestestablished logics in computer science. First order logic fol syntax o terms, predicates, atoms, literals, quantifiers, wff semantics o interpretations and models, valid, satisfiable, and inconsistent sentences, logical consequences o be able to translate between english sentences and fol sentences o. The case of must testing is perhaps surprising, as its mathematical definition involves universal quantification over the infinity of possible outcomes of a nondeterministic program. The validitysatisfiability in fol firstorder logic is undecidable.
I know the practical consequences of semi decidability of first order logic. Nonmonotonic logic and human reasoning in view of the fact that test subjects seem to perform very poorly in various paradigmatic reasoning tests e. Example resolution animal y x loves z x x loves u v kills u v. Entailment in predicate logic is only semidecidable. One of the first problems suspected to be undecidable, in the second sense of the term, was the word problem for groups, first posed by max dehn in 1911, which asks if there is a finitely presented group for which no algorithm exists to determine whether two words are equivalent. Firstorder logic fol is a richer language than propositional logic.
Review of sets, relations, computability, propositional and firstorder logic syntax, semantics, sequent calculus. Firstorder logic alphabet, 49 compactness, 147 completenessofhilbertcalculus, 144 constant symbols, 49 function symbols, 48 gentzen calculus, 152 hilbert calculus, 62 in. Semidecidability of may, must and probabilistic testing. Newest undecidability questions computer science stack. Lewis 33 showed that satisfiability is nexptimecomplete for ramseys class and kolaitis and vardi 29 proved that a 01 law holds for existential second order logic where the first order part. Using a satbased model finder to verify firstorder logic. Nonmonotonic logic stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Undecidability of validity and satisfiability 1 semidecidability of. Bridge summary computer programs to nd formal proofs of theorems have a history going back nearly half a century. Artificial intelligence 20192020 semidecidability of first order logic 5 prenex normal form pnf q 1 x 1 q 2 x 2 q n x n q i x x x x. Prenex normal form wikipedia firstorder resolution clausal form, unification, resolution method for first. This adequation holds in propositional logic and firstorder logic, but.
First a point is made for introducing a new operation. The main reason for that is the semidecidability and infinitary nature of higherorder unification algorithms, which requires the integration of unification within the calculus and results in a nonefficient search for refutations. Sat smtar introduction and applications akos hajdu. As such it is also a natural framework for abstract computations. Example resolution animal y x loves z x x loves u v school stanford university. Due to the semidecidability problem of fol, increasing the executiontime limit is not a solution for con.
77 1208 451 575 1318 1119 599 105 1161 286 1079 35 1133 667 274 729 566 1491 764 789 832 1476 1014 480 849 947 4 224 251 606 977 479 600 1107 400 229 1110 1329 291 1390 498 986 1128